Is Your Current School the Right Fit?

Written by 
Krista Pfeiffer

Teaching is more than a job—it’s a calling. But the environment in which you’re teaching can have a huge impact on your success and satisfaction. Just as different students can respond differently to the same teacher, different teachers can have different experiences at the same school. If you’re struggling with work-life balance, often feeling drained, or questioning if you’re truly making an impact, the culprit could be school fit.

Your work is essential. So, to make sure it is rewarding for you, it might help to assess if you’re doing it at the place that’s right for you. Here are some key areas to reflect on as you decide whether your current school is where you can truly thrive.

Clarify Your Goals and Values

Before you look outward, look inward. What do you want in the short and long term? If you’re early in your career, perhaps you crave mentorship and skill-building. Mid-career educators often prioritize balance and leadership opportunities. Some want to grow into administration; others prefer to deepen their impact in the classroom.

To determine your goals, ask yourself:

  • Where do I see myself in five years?
  • What skills do I want to develop?
  • Do I thrive most when collaborating, leading, or focusing on my classroom?

As you identify what you value most in a workplace, consider these aspects:

  • Collaboration: Do you trust the people you work with and feel you have common goals? Do you have sufficient time each week to plan or problem-solve with colleagues as much as you’d like to? 
  • Communication: Do you feel informed about important issues within the school? Do you know where to find the information you need to do your best work?
  • Decision-Making: Are you able to be as involved in decisions that affect you as you’d like to be? Do you understand leadership’s choices and feel they act with urgency and transparency?
  • Inclusion and Belonging: Do you feel the school puts appropriate emphasis on fostering an inclusive workplace? Do staff, students, and community members feel a sense of belonging?

Once you know your goals and values, compare them to your school’s mission and daily practices. Does the way your school operates align with your priorities? If not, it may not be the best place to support you.

Consider Opportunities for Growth

Professional growth keeps teaching fulfilling, but it shouldn’t be one-size-fits-all. Most schools provide mandatory professional development for all staff. If it’s varied and applicable, you’re in a good place.

Also look for individualized growth opportunities–especially early in your career or if you want to specialize. Some schools offer tuition reimbursement, flexible scheduling for graduate classes or per-teacher PD budgets. Take advantage of what’s available if growth is important to you.

Many teachers value opportunities to serve on committees, lead teams or coach colleagues. Decide what kind of growth matters to you and assess whether your school provides it.

Evaluate Resources and Support

Growth isn’t just about PD. Even the strongest teachers need support. Does your school provide the curriculum, materials, and technology you need? Are classrooms well maintained and safe? Is coverage available so you can attend trainings or take personal days without guilt? These supports free you to focus on students without added stress.

Measure Work-Life Balance

Perhaps the clearest sign of fit is how you feel day to day. Teaching is demanding, but you should still have energy for family, friends, or hobbies. If you’re usually feeling drained midweek, something is wrong.

Also consider commute, salary, and benefits. Even with positives elsewhere, a long commute or inadequate pay may not be sustainable. A good fit supports both your professional ambitions and your personal well-being.

Make a List and Compare

As you weigh these factors, it can help to create a pros and cons list. Include categories like culture, growth, compensation, and balance. Then, set priorities. A lower salary may be fine if you have a supportive team. But if the work environment clashes with your top priorities, even high pay may not make it worth your while.

Compare your list with data from other schools and insights from colleagues. Sometimes seeing things side by side makes the next step clear. Just remember: every school is different, and so is every teacher. What feels like a poor fit for you could be perfect for someone else.

Explore Possibilities

If your school aligns with your goals, supports your growth, and allows for balance, celebrate it and make the most of it.

But if your reflections reveal misalignments, it may be time for change. Give yourself permission to explore. That could mean advocating for improvements in your current role, or seeking a new opportunity. You deserve to teach in a place that values you as much as you value your students.

Since your needs and goals evolve, reassess every few years. Knowing yourself and seeking environments where you’ll thrive will help you be the best educator you can be.

Krista Pfeiffer
Teacher Marketing Manager

Find a teaching job you love️.

  • See all teaching jobs in one place
  • Set your preferences
  • Connect with principals

Stay Informed on education hiring and career trends!

Sign up for email updates to get job search tips, hiring trends, and insider insights.
Thank you!

Be on the lookout for email updates.
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
K-12 hiring tools that work

Find a teaching job you love.

We care about your data. Details in our privacy policy.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.